NewAI Part GeneratorFree to get started
Head to head

Quilter vs DeepPCB: Choosing an AI Autorouter

These two come up together constantly, and the comparisons usually turn into a feature list that misses what actually determines the outcome: how your specific board interacts with the free tier, and whether you can upload it at all.

Download for DesktopFree to start · macOS, Windows & Linux
Rishik Boddeti

By Rishik Boddeti · Last reviewed

Founder of ProtoFlow, ECE at UT Austin

Quick answer

Both are cloud AI services that take an existing board and produce placement and routing, with a free way in and paid usage at production size: Quilter has a free tier for teams under 10 people and $50K revenue, DeepPCB a one-time 30-minute trial. Quilter positions closer to full AI layout, taking on placement as well as routing. DeepPCB positions around automated placement and routing with pay-as-you-go pricing and caps on layers and connections during the trial. The decisive practical differences are usually the free limits against your actual board and team, and whether uploading the design to a third-party cloud is acceptable. If it is not, ProtoFlow routes locally with ProtoRoute on native KiCad files, free.

AI routing options compared (reviewed August 2026)

QuilterDeepPCBProtoFlow (ProtoRoute)
ModelCloud AI layout serviceCloud AI placement + routingLocal routing in the editor
Covers placementYesYesYou place parts in the PCB editor
Free entryFree tier with limits30-minute free trial + pay-as-you-goFree
Design upload requiredYesYesNo, stays local
Also does schematic captureNoNoYes, AI schematic generation
Validate outputRe-run DRC in your toolRe-run DRC in your toolDRC in the same editor

Skip the comparison shopping. Try the free one first and see if it does the job.

Download for Desktop

Prices and Plan Limits, Checked Against Vendor Pages

Each row links to the vendor page it came from and shows the date we last read that page. Vendors change pricing often, so check the link before you buy.

ProductPrice or limitSourceChecked
QuilterFree tier for personal, academic and eligible small-team use (under 10 people and $50K revenue); free-tier designs are used to train its modelsquilter.ai
QuilterCommercial use priced per project, quoted through salesquilter.ai
DeepPCBOne-time 30-minute free trial (1 board, up to 4 layers, 150 airwires), then prepaid pay-as-you-go credits (1 hour for $30)deeppcb.ai

They are both routing services, not design tools

This is the most useful thing to understand before comparing them. Neither Quilter nor DeepPCB creates your schematic, sources your components, or fixes a footprint. They start from a board that already exists and automate the physical work of arranging and connecting it. If your bottleneck is upstream, in capture, part selection, or library gaps, neither of these solves it.

That also means they slot into an existing flow rather than replacing it. You design elsewhere, hand off, and bring the routed result back into your own tool for checking.

How to actually choose between them

Test both on the board you actually have. Quilter's free tier and DeepPCB's free trial exist precisely so you can do this, and the limits, team size and revenue for Quilter, board count, layer count and airwires for DeepPCB's trial, are where the two diverge in practice far more than in their marketing. A design or team that fits one service's free offer can fall outside the other's on a single dimension.

Then judge the output the same way for both: open the routed board in your own CAD tool, run DRC with your fabricator's real capability rules, and look at how the critical nets were handled. That is a comparison you can trust, unlike a generic verdict from someone routing a different board.

The question that rules both out for some teams

Both services require uploading your design. For a lot of work that is entirely fine. For pre-release hardware under NDA, defense or medical work, or a company whose policy simply forbids it, it is a hard stop, and no amount of routing quality changes that.

ProtoFlow's ProtoRoute engine routes on your machine, in the same free desktop editor that does schematic capture, part import, ERC, and DRC, on native KiCad files. It is a different trade, a local engine against dedicated cloud services that specialize in nothing else, but it is the option that exists when uploading is not permitted.

What to do with the output, whichever you pick

Route the nets that carry real constraints by hand first: high-speed differential pairs, RF, and heavy power distribution. Lock them. Then let the automation handle the dense digital and the fan-out, which is where it genuinely saves hours.

Afterwards, always re-run DRC in your own tool against your fabricator's published capability rather than the defaults. A service checks against the constraints it was given; only you know what your fab can build.

Decision Matrix

CriteriaProtoFlowQuilter / DeepPCB
Where the design goesStays on your machine.Uploaded to the service.
Routing specializationLocal engine, integrated with DRC.Dedicated specialists, often stronger.
Covers the schematic stageYes, AI capture and part import.No, board must already exist.
Cost at prototype scaleFree.Quilter free tier with eligibility limits; DeepPCB 30-minute trial.
Cost at production scaleFree.Paid usage.

Migration Steps

  1. Finish capture and ERC first. Routing automation cannot fix an upstream problem.
  2. Hand-route and lock the high-speed, RF, and power-critical nets.
  3. Run the same board through Quilter's free tier and DeepPCB's free trial and see which one your design fits inside.
  4. Open each routed result in your own CAD tool and run DRC against your fabricator's capability rules.
  5. If uploading the design is not permitted, route locally in ProtoFlow instead.

How These Two Were Compared

Reviewed on: 2026-08-09

Methodology

  • Selected the target query for this page from the Search Console export for protoflow.ai through August 7, 2026, filtered to query families that already earn impressions but have no page owning the intent, then joined against Google Keyword Planner US monthly volume pulled July 20, 2026.
  • Reviewed the official site, pricing page, documentation, or public repository of every tool named on this page in August 2026.
  • Kept only workflow- and source-checkable claims. Nothing on this page is presented as a hands-on benchmark, a speed measurement, or a head-to-head test result.

Findings

  • Both services are described by what their own sites and documentation claim as of August 2026, including Quilter's free tier, DeepPCB's one-time free trial, and paid usage at scale.
  • Specific free-tier and trial limits change, so they are quoted with the date they were checked; the guidance is to check them against your actual board before committing.
  • No routing-quality benchmark is claimed. Nothing on this page reports a head-to-head test result.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Quilter or DeepPCB?

There is no general answer worth trusting, because the outcome depends on your board. Quilter has a free tier with eligibility limits and DeepPCB a one-time 30-minute trial, so run your actual design through each and compare the routed output in your own tool with your own DRC rules.

Are Quilter and DeepPCB free?

Quilter offers a free tier for personal, academic and small-team use (under 10 people and $50K revenue), and free-tier designs train its models; DeepPCB offers a one-time 30-minute trial (1 board, up to 4 layers, 150 airwires), then pay-as-you-go. Both charge for production boards, so check the current limits before you plan a workflow around either.

Do I have to upload my design to use an AI autorouter?

For cloud services, yes. If that is not acceptable, ProtoFlow routes locally with its ProtoRoute engine in a free desktop editor working on native KiCad files, so the design never leaves your machine.

Is AI routing good enough for production boards?

It is genuinely useful for dense digital sections, fan-out, and revision churn, and it saves real hours there. High-speed, RF, and power-dense sections still deserve manual routing. Route those first, lock them, automate the rest, and run DRC against your fabricator's real capability before release.

Sources

Related Resources

Try ProtoFlow EDA

Evaluate the workflow directly with your own circuit scope and compare review-ready output speed.